Kaley Cuoco Might Finally Have Her Real Big Bang Theory Replacement With Returning Murder Mystery Show

A returning murder mystery show seems to have the potential to become the perfect Big Bang Theory replacement for Kaley Cuoco. In a career spanning over 30 years, Kaley Cuoco has starred in a diverse set of movies and TV shows. From portraying Harley Quinn in the DC TV show to portraying the relatively smaller role of Sasha in Prison Break, the actress has displayed remarkable versatility throughout her career. However, despite having so many roles in her acting portfolio, she is best known for playing Penny in The Big Bang Theory.

The Big Bang Theory ended its long run in 2019 after 12 seasons. Since then, Kaley Cuoco has stayed fairly active as an actor and has starred in several movies and shows, like Curd Your EnthusiasmThe Man From Toronto, and Role Play. However, none of these have given her the long-running highs of success that she achieved with The Big Bang Theory. Fortunately, it looks like this is about to change with her returning murder mystery show.

Based On A True Story Can Become Kaley Cuoco's Big Bang Theory Replacement Show

The Show Has Already Been Renewed For Another Season

 

Kaley Cuoco's Penny smiles with a lime in her mouth as Johnny Galecki's Leonard smiles nervously on a couch in The Big Bang Theory

Jim Parsons' Sheldon and Kaley Cuoco's Amy stand in the elevator in The Big Bang Theory

Kaley Cuoco's Penny looks at Jim Parsons' Sheldon as he stares at socks in The Big Bang Theory

Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina looking stunned at something in Based on a True story teaser

Kaley Cuoco looking surprised in Based On A True Story season 1, episode 3

Kaley Cuoco's Penny smiles with a lime in her mouth as Johnny Galecki's Leonard smiles nervously on a couch in The Big Bang Theory

Jim Parsons' Sheldon and Kaley Cuoco's Amy stand in the elevator in The Big Bang Theory

Kaley Cuoco's Penny looks at Jim Parsons' Sheldon as he stares at socks in The Big Bang Theory

Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina looking stunned at something in Based on a True story teaser

Kaley Cuoco looking surprised in Based On A True Story season 1, episode 3

Created by Craig Rosenberg, Based on a True Story features Kaley Cuoco as its leading character, who is a pregnant real estate agent named Ava. The show's entire first season unfolds as a compelling comedy thriller that walks through how Ava puts her obsession with true crime to good use to find the truth about a mysterious murderer. When it comes to story developments and themes, Based on a True Story is almost nothing like The Big Bang Theory.

However, the show's comical aspects and Cuoco's ability to balance humor with intensity in both shows make it hard not to see Based on a True Story as her potential Big Bang Theory replacement. Following its first season, Based on a True Story also received favorable reviews from most viewers and critics. The show has also been renewed for another season, which paves the way for it to have as epic of a long-term run as The Big Bang Theory. Although it may be too soon to compare the Based on a True Story with The Big Bang Theory, it could eventually become equally successful.

The Flight Attendant Was Supposed To Be Kaley Cuoco's Big Bang Theory Replacement – Why It Ended After 2 Seasons

The Flight Attendant Was Canceled By HBO Max

 

Kaley Cuoco as Cassandra looking sad in The Flight Attendant

Cassie looking nervous in The Flight Attendant season 2

Kaley Cuoco as Cassie talking to herself in The Flight Attendant

Kaley Cuoco as Cassie on the phone in The Flight Attendant

Kaley Cuoco as Cassie spies through red binoculars in The Flight Attendant

Kaley Cuoco as Cassandra looking sad in The Flight Attendant

Cassie looking nervous in The Flight Attendant season 2

Kaley Cuoco as Cassie talking to herself in The Flight Attendant

Kaley Cuoco as Cassie on the phone in The Flight Attendant

Kaley Cuoco as Cassie spies through red binoculars in The Flight Attendant

Kaley Cuoco Shows

Avg. Rotten Tomatoes Critics Score Across All Seasons

Based On A True Story

76%

The Big Bang Theory

81%

The Flight Attendant

91%

Before Kaley Cuoco took on the role of the true-crime enthusiast in Based on a True Story, she portrayed the titular character in the dark comedy series The Flight Attendant. Following its release in November 2020, The Flight Attendant was received incredibly well by critics and its first season still boasts an impressive Rotten Tomatoes score of 97%. Its success encouraged HBO Max to renew it for another season a month after season 1's release.

Although The Flight Attendant's season 2 was considered a relatively inferior installment compared to season 2 by many, the show still earned an 86% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Unfortunately, despite the positive critical reception, The Flight Attendant was canceled after season 2. What made its cancelation even more disappointing is that it allowed Kaley Cuoco to leverage her strengths with her comic timing and dramatic depth. However, the actress had already predicted the show's end, saying (via TV Line) that season 3 should only happen if it promises to be better than the first two.

How Based On A True Story Can Continue For A Bigger Future Beyond Season 2

The Show Has Immense Scope For Growth

 

Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina hold bloody mops while looking distraught in Based on a True Story

Natalia Dyer's dead body on the floor in Based on a True Story

Tom Bateman as Matt, who is smiling in Based on a True Story

Priscilla Quintana wears a nice red dress in Based on a True Story

Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina looking towards camera in Based On A True Story

Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina hold bloody mops while looking distraught in Based on a True Story

Natalia Dyer's dead body on the floor in Based on a True Story

Tom Bateman as Matt, who is smiling in Based on a True Story

Priscilla Quintana wears a nice red dress in Based on a True Story

Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina looking towards camera in Based On A True Story

Although Based on a True Story's season 1 final arc provides some concrete answers surrounding its overarching mysteries, many of its story developments remain unresolved. With so many loose threads after its first season, Based on a True Story has the potential to scale its storyline to new heights in subsequent seasons. By expanding on its established plotlines, the series can maintain viewer engagement and even have a long, solid run. Based on a True Story may be able to last as long as The Big Bang Theory, but it certainly can etch its own identity in the thriller comedy genre and give Kaley Cuoco another memorable signature role.

Related Posts

Chuck Lorre Instituted a Permanent Ban in The Big Bang Theory Because of Kaley Cuoco: ‘The darkest, most frightening time in all 12 years’

Chuck Lorre dropped a bombshell back in the day when he instituted a permanent ban on a certain topic during The Big Bang Theory. And it all…

“It had a tone that felt very comfortable to me”: Kaley Cuoco’s Reasoning Behind Joining ‘Based on a True Story’ is Extremely Disturbing That Many Fans Can Relate With

Known for her standout performances in shows like The Big Bang Theory and The Flight Attendant, Kaley Cuoco made a striking return to television with a new…

Kaley Cuoco Was Surprised With the Most Unhinged Rumors About Her Feud With Margot Robbie: ‘I’ve never even met her’

Who would have thought the popular DC villain Harley Quinn could spark a rumored feud between Kaley Cuoco and Margot Robbie, who portrayed the character in their…

Kaley Cuoco’s Themed-Photo of Daughter Matilda Shows She ‘Knows What’s Important in This Family’

While we all know that Kaley Cuoco loves all things animals, her fiancé Tom Pelphrey loves something you may not expect: football. Before becoming an actor, Pelphrey…

Kaley Cuoco’s Penny Almost Wasn’t A Human In The Big Bang Theory

When a sitcom lasts 12 seasons, there's a good chance it'll undergo some nips and tucks over the years to keep it looking and feeling fresh. "Will…

Kaley Cuoco Says Daughter Matilda ‘Knows What’s Important in This Family’ as She Jokes About Fiancé’s Love of Football

Kaley Cuoco and her daughter Matilda are shopping in style. On Friday, Oct. 4, the Big Bang Theory alum shared photos to her Instagram Stories of her…